Why hiring feels stuck › Hiring tools

What each of your hiring tools does well

Most companies use a mix of job boards, recruiters, referrals and their own people. Each one has a place. The trouble starts when you count on one of them for something it was never built to do.

A professional on a phone call near a conference room

Seven ways companies find people, side by side.

ToolWhere it helpsWhat to watchWhere it fits in a plan
Job boards and job sitesReaches a lot of active job seekers fast. Useful for high-volume roles, including the trades.Posts lose visibility after a few days unless you pay. Paid placements add up, and free boards rarely produce much.Necessary for many roles. Works best when each post leads to a careers page that tells your story.
LinkedIn and other social mediaA personal post about an opening can travel through your network and bring strong referrals.Paid job posts are expensive, and a popular post can bury one person in messages. One hiring manager told Broadview she received more than 3,000 applicants and messages for one posting.Keeps you in front of people between openings, as well as during them.
Employee referralsA reliable source of good people, because your employees know the work and the culture.Whether referrals happen on purpose or only by chance.Belongs in every plan, with a story your team can share.
Outside recruitersMost charge only when someone is hired, and good recruiters bring relationships you don’t have.Where your search sits on their list, and whether your contract covers a new hire who leaves early.Valuable for senior and specialized roles. A clear plan gives them more to work with.
Applicant tracking systemCollects and sorts applications, and screens out people who don’t meet the requirements.Filters are designed to “keep the good and reject the not qualified,” but often great candidates for current or future roles end up in the “no” pile over resume formatting or other reasons, leaving a list of strong candidates that remain forgotten.Past applicants become a source of future hires.
Handling it in-houseYou keep control, and no one knows your company better.Do recruiting and hiring lag due to other responsibilities of the person responsible for hiring?Works well when someone is dedicated and the resources are available to manage effectively. Outside support is often needed regardless of the role or size of company.
Recruitment marketingBuilds interest in your company before jobs open, so the right people are ready when you need them.Takes planning, outside the box thinking, and patience at the start. Works best when leadership is on board and there’s a projected amount of hiring ahead.Ties all the best tools together, including job boards and third-party recruiters, into one proactive recruitment marketing program.

Job boards and job sites

Where it helps
Reaches a lot of active job seekers fast. Useful for high-volume roles, including the trades.
What to watch
Posts lose visibility after a few days unless you pay. Paid placements add up, and free boards rarely produce much.
Where it fits in a plan
Necessary for many roles. Works best when each post leads to a careers page that tells your story.

LinkedIn and other social media

Where it helps
A personal post about an opening can travel through your network and bring strong referrals.
What to watch
Paid job posts are expensive, and a popular post can bury one person in messages. One hiring manager told Broadview she received more than 3,000 applicants and messages for one posting.
Where it fits in a plan
Keeps you in front of people between openings, as well as during them.

Employee referrals

Where it helps
A reliable source of good people, because your employees know the work and the culture.
What to watch
Whether referrals happen on purpose or only by chance.
Where it fits in a plan
Belongs in every plan, with a story your team can share.

Outside recruiters

Where it helps
Most charge only when someone is hired, and good recruiters bring relationships you don’t have.
What to watch
Where your search sits on their list, and whether your contract covers a new hire who leaves early.
Where it fits in a plan
Valuable for senior and specialized roles. A clear plan gives them more to work with.

Applicant tracking system

Where it helps
Collects and sorts applications, and screens out people who don’t meet the requirements.
What to watch
Filters are designed to “keep the good and reject the not qualified,” but often great candidates for current or future roles end up in the “no” pile over resume formatting or other reasons, leaving a list of strong candidates that remain forgotten.
Where it fits in a plan
Past applicants become a source of future hires.

Handling it in-house

Where it helps
You keep control, and no one knows your company better.
What to watch
Do recruiting and hiring lag due to other responsibilities of the person responsible for hiring?
Where it fits in a plan
Works well when someone is dedicated and the resources are available to manage effectively. Outside support is often needed regardless of the role or size of company.

Recruitment marketing

Where it helps
Builds interest in your company before jobs open, so the right people are ready when you need them.
What to watch
Takes planning, outside the box thinking, and patience at the start. Works best when leadership is on board and there’s a projected amount of hiring ahead.
Where it fits in a plan
Ties all the best tools together, including job boards and third-party recruiters, into one proactive recruitment marketing program.

A better comparison

Four questions that show whether your current tools are working for you

Most companies compare hiring tools by what they cost up front. A better way to judge any approach you are using is to ask yourself these four questions. If your current mix of tools isn’t moving any of those in the right direction, it may be time to look at doing things differently.

How recruitment marketing works
Your hiring scorecardUse these to judge any approach
  1. Speed and quality

    Are we filling jobs faster with people we’re glad we hired?

  2. Total cost

    How is the total cost of hiring impacting your company? Is the total cost of hiring going down over time, or does it start over with every opening?

  3. Fit and retention

    Are the people we are hiring the right fit from the beginning? How long are they staying once they are hired?

  4. Leadership time

    Are our leaders spending less time on hiring?

One plan for all of your hiring tools

Recruitment marketing connects the tools you already use around the hiring you expect.

What is recruitment marketing?