Why good people are so hard to find right now
It’s easy to blame pay, benefits, the economy, or lack of resources as to why jobs sit open longer than they should, and each of those definitely plays a part. The truth for growing companies is that the people applying are not always the best fit for a company’s needs. You may be a great company and a fantastic place to work, but not able to attract and retain the best talent, and still trying to figure out why that is.

Nine reasons the right candidates aren’t reaching you
Where candidates look
Your jobs are hard to find
The right people are out there searching. They never see your job.

-
Reason 1: Your job posts are getting buriedWithin a few hours or a day, newer posts push yours out of sight unless you pay to keep it near the top.
On the big job sites, unpaid job posts only sit near the top briefly, a few hours or a day, before newer posts push them down and they become harder to find unless you pay a premium to keep them at the top of the pile. Those who then apply to your jobs are often unqualified or not a good fit for your company, which is discouraging.
It’s easy to blame a slow market. More often, the right people never saw the post.
-
Reason 2: Your careers page is turning people awayCandidates check your website next. A careers page that’s hard to find and use sends them elsewhere.
Once someone finds one of your jobs, the first place they go is your website. Within seconds, they decide whether your company looks like a place they’d want to work.
A careers page buried at the bottom of the site, or one that is not mobile-enabled, will cost a company qualified candidates. That matters more every year. Many younger workers and people in the trades search and apply entirely on their phones, and some don’t own a computer.
-
Reason 3: Your recruiters have other clients, tooThey spend their time on the searches most likely to pay off. Yours may not be one of them.
Third-party recruiters are a good tool, and companies that hire often should use them. Most are paid only when they place someone, as a percentage of first-year salary. That’s a fair arrangement.
It also means they focus on the searches most likely to close. If your role is hard to fill or the pay is on the lower end, your search can slide down the list without anyone telling you. A month with no candidates is a warning sign.
Try this: search for one of your open jobs the way a candidate would, on your phone.
What candidates hear
Candidates never hear your story
A job post lists requirements and pay. It says nothing about why someone would want to work for you.

-
Reason 4: A job ad is all candidates ever seeIt tells people a role is open and little about who you are and why they should come work for you.
Posting a job on Indeed or LinkedIn is a critical part of advertising, but it is not true recruitment marketing. Marketing open positions the way you market your products or services as a company shifts the focus to proactive advertising vs. reactive.
-
Reason 5: Good candidates never hear why you’re a great place to workSo they compare you on pay and benefits alone.
Mid-sized, high-growth companies often can’t match what the bigger employers pay nor the level of benefits they can offer. What they offer instead is a better culture, more flexibility or a real chance to grow.
A job post is a poor place to say any of that. Candidates compare the numbers, and a growing company rarely wins on numbers alone.
-
Reason 6: Paying well doesn’t guarantee the right applicantsStrong pay brings in volume. It doesn’t necessarily attract the right people for your company.
We hear this one a lot: “We pay very well and have excellent benefits, so we get a flood of candidates who often aren’t the right fit.”
Pay and benefits prompt people to apply, which is good, but only one component to hiring people who are a good fit for you and you for them. Without the full picture, you may spend time on applicants who are not who you really want to hire.
“Most companies aren’t marketing who they are or the kind of people they want working for them. They’re only advertising.”
Julie Pitts, Founder and Principal
Inside your company
Hiring starts too late and lands on busy people
Most companies know hiring is coming. Few have anyone with time to plan for it.

-
Reason 7: You start looking the day the job opensMany companies know which roles are coming and still start from zero.
Many even know which roles they’ll fill next year. Without a plan to find those people, they wait until the position opens and start from scratch.
By then the work is piling up, and the people you wanted have already taken other offers.
-
Reason 8: Hiring falls on people who already have full-time jobsThe owner, an office manager or an HR person with plenty of other work.
In most small and mid-sized companies, hiring is one of many jobs the owner or HR person carries. Marketing is focused on customer attraction, not candidate attraction.
Most of the people responsible for hiring would like to do it differently. They don’t have time to step back and rethink it, so the same approach to hiring continues.
-
Reason 9: Turnover starts with reactive hiring practices and rushed hiresRushed hires are more likely to leave, and then the search starts over.
When a seat has to be filled fast, it’s easy to hire whoever is available and looks good on paper or interviews well. We’ve seen that scenario play out repeatedly, and unfortunately, those candidates rarely last.
When that person leaves, you pay again for the search and the training. When the right people never hear about you, you’re always choosing from whoever happens to apply.
“You need the pipeline before you actually need those people.”
Julie Pitts, Founder and Principal
If nothing changes
Hiring problems rarely stay the same size
One slow search sets off the next.
Open roles take longer to fill
The work waits or lands on someone else.
People covering get overworked
Some of them start to leave, too.
Rushed hires miss the mark
Wrong-fit hires lead to more turnover.
Hiring costs become hard to predict
Every opening turns into its own emergency.
Two years from now, the company that planned to grow may find it harder to do so because they can’t find the right people at the right times to do the work.
